That's not cool that Pemco dropped an existing house. I can see not accepting one when they change their requirements but to drop someone already insured is wrong.
We have Farmers. My husband has been with this guy for over 20 years. We're low maintenance with no claims or accidents or anything like that. When I called to add the MG, he said liability would be the best. I started checking around and it could easily be covered by collectors insurance. I gathered tons of info, talked to the major insurers of old cars, and called our guy back. He got MAD at me! Then he started lying, just one after another. Every time I countered back with my findings, he would find something else. I only called him to see if we could go through him to use a different type policy. Finally he said going to another insurance for this car would do something to our umbrella policy and it would waive the fact we're covered driving rental cars. It was really strange his whole reaction and he was so wrong on a lot of things because I asked a lot of questions when I talked to the collector insurance people.
This is how it started. My feeling is if he can't insure the car because normal insurance doesn't work for this car, work with us to find a solution. I think it's to the point that we'll go elsewhere even if the rates are the same.
Thanks for all the info though. Now I have a few ideas and I know who won't cover the house too.